|
| |
Scroll Down to Read Articles
FPS
Fall 2000 Meeting Honors
Late Thomas Kay Buchanan, M.D.
Psychiatrists
Fight Back at NFETC
I'm
Back!: Emily Grimm
Auxiliary
Report Spring Meeting April 2000 Report: George L. Warren, M.D., Editor
Windy City Report: George L. Warren, M.D., Editor
This
issue of Transference was a special issue for the FPS Fall Meeting
October 5 - 8, 2000 at the Hyatt Regency Pier 66 in Fort Lauderdale.
The
meeting focused on community psychiatry and public health and
prevention and was in honor of Thomas Kay Buchanan, MD. The following is a
biography of Dr. Buchanan.
Thomas
Kay Buchanan was born July 9, 1923, in Imlay City, Michigan, a small town
of 1500 inhabitants, affectionately called "The Garden Spot of
Eastern Michigan" and "The Gateway to the Thumb." His
father, Ernest, owned a restaurant and his mother, Mary Edith, was a
nurse. It was her desire from the day he was born that he would become a
doctor.
They
lived next door to an Italian family with four children, one of whom was
Gene Coscarelli, his best buddy who became his dearest lifelong friend.
Gene's father would come home early for dinner, then go back to his store
for evening hours. His mother would invite "the little blond
bambino," who was usually at her house to eat with them, which he
did. When his own father came home for dinner, Kay (as he was called by
everyone) was not hungry, leaving his mother to worry that he must be sick
- even though he was the chubbiest little boy on the block. It took a
while for Mrs. Buchanan to figure out that her only child was not
starving, but eating that good Italian food next door.
Growing
up he had a newspaper route, which he walked in the winter and early
spring. One fateful day, he made the mistake of not noticing that one of
his customers had just seeded a new lawn on his very large corner lot. Kay
started at one corner, went diagonally across the yard to the porch, then
across the other way to the street, sinking in several inches with each
big step. The lady of the house looked out her kitchen window and
exclaimed in a very LOUD voice, "Larry, will you just LOOK at that
big lummox of a Kay Buchanan 'kerplunking' across my new lawn!"
Little did she realize that
he would grow into a handsome 6'3" athlete who would become her
son-in-law, eleven years later.
Kay
became a very loved young man in his community and his school, playing
three sports - basketball, football and baseball - lettering in all three.
He was captain of the basketball team, president of his class and
valedictorian. He played first chair baritone in the band. He loved to
dance.
He
enrolled as a freshman at the University, of Michigan in the Pre-Med
program in 1941, just a few months before Pearl Harbor. He pledged the
Acacia Fraternity, went out for Freshman basketball and won his Freshman
numerals. He always regretted that he did not go out for
the Michigan basketball team, but thought he should concentrate on
his studies in order to get into medical school. His high school coach had
assured him that he would have made the team.
Near
the end of his Sophomore year, he began trying to enlist in a branch of
the armed services, but kept failing the physical because of his eyesight.
He was finally accepted by the Seabeas and was sent to the Marshall
Islands for fifteen months where he served in a M.A.S.H. unit. Returning
from overseas, he was sent to Philadelphia Naval Hospital where he served
as a Medical Technologist Corpsman for the remainder of the war. While
there he played basketball for the Naval Hospital.
Kay
was discharged from the Navy in July, 1946, returned to the University of
Michigan in the fall of that year, helped re-open the fraternity house,
and was elected president of the Acacia Fraternity, helping to rebuild the
group after the war.
One
evening, he and his buddy 'Bearcat' noticed a young woman with her
eight-year old sister at the
Lapeer County Fair, eating at the Rotary stand. It turned out to be
someone he had known most of his life, named Donna Marie Thatcher .
They stopped to say "hello". "That nice little Thatcher girl" had
gone to the same church, played in the band since seventh grade, was a
high school cheerleader and had been on the same team buses with him all
those years, but something was different. SHE HAD GROWN UP DURING THE PAST
THREE YEARS.
Since
Donna and her little sister needed a ride home, Bearcat and Buck (as Kay
was now called from his days on the football team) offered to borrow
Bearcat's father's car and give them a lift. After putting her sister to
bed, Donna and the boys began talking
in the living room. At midnight, Bearcat realized the fairgrounds had
closed, and his Dad (with a true Irish temper) must have had to walk
home!!!! They rushed to the door, Buck pushed Bearcat out on the porch,
shut the door behind him, turned around and gave Donna a great BIG kiss
and whispered in her ear, "I'll see you in Ann Arbor."
The
rest is history. The next weekend, back on campus, Kay invited Donna to a
dance in the ballroom of the Men's Student Union and Kay never dated
another girl again. Donna became the "Sweetheart of Acacia", Kay
gave her his Fraternity pin, and the fraternity brothers serenaded Donna
under her window. This Fraternity tradition meant they were "engaged
to be engaged". Kay & Donna became "officially" engaged
the day Kay was accepted to the U. of M. Medical School, and were married
at the end of Kay's first year on June 26,1948. As Kay always said -
"We had a true storybook college romance."
Their
wedding was a BIG social event in their little hometown. Both were
children of prominent businessmen and the guest list was carefully made
out to make certain that all 300 guests would have a seat in the little
church. However, no one expected twenty-two Acacia Fraternity brothers and
their dates would turn up (after receiving one courtesy invitation) and
fill almost one quarter of the church. The remainder of the guests sat in
the choir loft. Even then,
Donna's favorite uncle had to stand up!
Dr.
Tom became a member of the First Baptist Church of Imlay City when he was
twelve years old. He always held to high moral standards and was a role
model for those around him. His faith brought him through some very
difficult times and also brought him much joy, peace and strength
throughout his life. He was always proud to be called and known as a
"Christian Psychiatrist". People
who knew and loved him, always recognized his love of God, which shone
through his dealings with others.
Dr.
Tom received his B.S. degree in 1948 and graduated from the University of
Michigan Medical School in June, 1951. He served his internship at St.
Mary's Hospital in Grand Rapids, Michigan, and then moved back to his
hometown of Imlay City to practice Family Medicine, which he did for eight
years. During that time, he delivered over 1200 babies, was Chief of
Pediatrics at the Lapeer County General Hospital, made house calls and
farm calls throughout the large rural area, and assisted Dr. Clare Bishop
of Almont, Michigan in surgery several mornings a week.
His
patients loved him because he treated them as family. One day he went out
to see a little old couple to let them know that he would be gone for a
month to Florida on vacation- He assured them that his partner would take
good care of them while he was gone. The little old lady patted him on the
hand and said, "that's all right Dr. Kay, don't you worry about us.
We will be just fine 'till you get back."
In
August 1960 he left general practice and returned to Ann Arbor for a
three-year residency in Psychiatry at Ypsilanti State Hospital and the U.
of M. He remained on staff for two more years, having received two grants
from NIMH for starting the first Alcohol Treatment Program for Women in a
state hospital in Michigan. He graduated from the Yale University Graduate
School of Alcohol Studies in 1961.
Dr.
Buchanan always loved the month each winter when he would take his family
to Florida for vacation. He and Donna were never ready to return home to
Michigan, so in 1965 he applied for and was hired to be Executive Director
of the Henderson Clinic, a small facility on Riverland Road in Ft.
Lauderdale. He had a staff of ten and was the only psychiatrist.
He
applied for and received the first Federal grants for community mental
health in Broward County. Over the years he built the clinic into a full
service Community Mental Health Center, with seven facilities throughout
the county and over 250 mental health professionals on staff.
His
accomplishments in Broward
County and the State of Floridainclude:
Starting
the first Alcoholism Treatment Program in Broward.
Serving
as a charter member of the Broward County Commission on Alcoholism, which
started one of the first DUI schools in the area.
Developing
a program for teens in distress, so that pregnant teens could finish high
school.
Teaching
alcohol and drug abuse treatment classes for nursing students at BCC.
Helping
to organize advocacy groups for the mentally Ill.
Serving
as a member and first chairman of the Florida State Indigent Drug Program.
Serving
as President of the Broward County Psychiatric Society.
Serving
as the first Community Psychiatrist to be elected President of the Florida
Psychiatric Society.
Being
elected as a Fellow and Life Fellow of the American Psychiatric
Association.
Tom
Buchanan served in many ways at First Baptist Church of Pompano including,
being ordained as a Deacon in 1967, teaching a men's Bible class, singing
in the choir for many years, serving as a Youth Choir Sponsor and traveled
as the group's physician on Concert Tours, serving as a member of the
Finance Committee and advisor to the Pastor for programs involving
counseling.
His
wife remained his Sweetheart.
His
family was his first priority - his
pride and joy.
His
children loved him dearly.
He
cherished his wonderful friends. He found time for whomever needed him,
and his beautiful smile and infectious laugh warmed the hearts of all who
knew him.
Thomas
K. Buchanan, M.D. is survived by his wife, Donna; his children Julie Kay
Drewry, Thomas K. Buchanan, Jr., Mary Anne Cooley; five grandchildren,
Bradley Thomas Drewry, Thomas Kay Buchanan, III, Elizabeth Anne Buchanan,
Lauren Alexandra Cooley, and David Thomas Cooley.
PSYCHIATRISTS
FIGHT BACK AT NFETC
by
Wade C. Myers, MD
Psychiatrists
at North Florida Evaluation and Treatment Center have been locked in battle with
their administrator, Denny Gies, and institution psychologists, led by Monte
Bein, Ph.D., Director of the NFETC Psychology Department, over what has been
termed the "Matrix"-the "Shared Responsibility Treatment Team
Model." Historically, this
forensic hospital located in Gainesville, FL, has treated
persons identified as incompetent to stand trial or not guilty by reason
of insanity using a Multidisciplinary Treatment Team (MDT) led by a
psychiatrist. I personally had the
opportunity to work under this traditional model for one year in the late 80's
while in my forensic psychiatry fellowship and recall this approach having
worked smoothly and effectively, with good team morale and an orderly chain of
command.
The
Matrix, developed and spearheaded by Mr. Gies, is a document which explicitly
requires agreement by non-medical personnel in the medical decision-making
process. The attempt to implement
this plan has led to chaos in team functioning, with conflicts over
responsibilities and leadership, arguments among MDT members, decreased morale,
and a tense work atmosphere. All of
these factors impair communication among team members, ultimately affecting the
ability of the MDT to administer quality medical care.
One is reminded of the nefarious vying for power and leadership in the
novel "Lord of the Flies."
Relatedly, of great concern and adding to the chaos, is the appointment
of a non-medical individual, Mr. Don Walsh, to the medical directorship
following the resignation of their psychiatrist Medical Director about two years
ago. Thus, the psychiatrists have
lost an administrative voice to protect the dispensation of quality medical
care.
The
NFETC psychiatrists sought relief by requesting a Declaratory Statement by the
Florida Board of Medicine. Reportedly,
Mr. Walsh and a member of the Department of Children and Families (DCAF) program
office attempted to have the Board of Medicine delay their ruling on this
matter. Notwithstanding, the Board
recently ruled (June 2000) in favor of these beleaguered physicians', stating
that if they practiced under the Matrix's shared responsibility model, it would
constitute substandard care. And
the Board of Medicine does have the authority to interpret "standard of
care" requirements for physicians. Of
note, in the Declaratory Statement, the Board of Medicine noted that Mr. Gies
had "...announced that the petitioning physicians would no longer have
final clinical decision-making authority regarding the treatment of patients at
the facility [NFETC]." Moreover,
the Matrix would "...shift final decision-making authority to a team of
physicians, psychologists, and administrators."
Did
this ruling actually bring relief for these physicians?
No. Mr. Gies and his
supporters are pushing ahead with the Matrix.
Dr. Bein has told the psychiatrists that his department will continue to
practice under the Matrix. Treating
psychologists under his auspices have parroted his position to the
psychiatrists. Social workers are experiencing confusion over what
model to follow. An investigative
group from Department of Children and Families came to NFETC to investigate this
situation, but did not support the position of the physicians.
DCAF reportedly did support the reestablishment of a physician to serve
as the medical director but we have not seen the report.
Currently,
the psychiatrists are faced with practicing under the Matrix, putting them at
risk of loss of licensure, malpractice suits, and violations of the AMA Code of
Medical Ethics, or not practicing at NFETC.
Neither alternative serves the health care needs of the chronically
mentally ill patients at NFETC, who have become sacrificial lambs in this thinly
veiled scope of practice issue. Mr.
Gies responded to the psychiatrists' proclamation of their inability to practice
in this setting by noting, "If you feel you can no longer work here, I will
assist you in relocating." Presumably,
he hopes the next batch of physicians will not be so attentive to the standard
of care.
"Nothing
Endures But Change"
Daniel Castellanos, M.D.
Heraclitus
once said, "Nothing endures
but change." After 29
years as separate district branches the reintegration of the Florida Psychiatric
Society and the South Florida Psychiatric Society has been successfully
completed. The time for the change
was right. We now must focus on our
mission as a collective organization. Our
goals are, and have been, the same for many years.
Gone are the sports and military analogies in which we are competing with
each other. Much of this year
will focus on continuing the process of integration.
We
will continue to focus on three main areas:
1)
Membership
2)
Advocacy
3)
Finances
Each
member of the society is truly an asset. Among
other things, we exist for the benefit of our members.
We will continue to look to increase recruitment of new members and
decrease attrition of our current members.
I and other FPS leadership will attempt to attend as many as possible of
the Chapter meetings around the state. We
will demonstrate that the FPS leadership is serving its members.
We will use these opportunities to understand what the problems each
psychiatrist is encountering in their part of the state.
We will share with each of you what we are trying to accomplish and what
we are actively trying to do about it.
Understanding the process is important.
Participation is a must!
Advocacy
comes in many forms. We are
definitely continuing our work on scope of practice issues. Non-physicians from all fields are trying to expand the scope
of their practices, affecting quality of care and potentially endangering the
lives the patients. We expect to
continue to address the plight of the mentally ill throughout the state.
Parity or nondiscrimination of mental illness remains a priority.
Advocacy for patients, the public and psychiatrists across the state will
remain a priority.
Finances
and fiscal responsibility are important issues as old as time.
With the reintegration of the Societies we find ourselves in a unique
situation where we can take a step back and look at our financial situation (as
if we hadn't done it before). We
hope to be opportunistic and utilize the situation to examine if the grouping of
the memberships will allow for different opportunities in the use of our
precious financial resources.
As
many of you know, Dodi Shellow is retiring as Executive Director of the SFPS.
We hope that she will remain as consultant to FPS.
Her dedication, energy and expertise will be missed.
Our
FPS staff remains tireless in their efforts.
Emily Grimm has returned as Associate Director and will work on meeting
planning and continuing medical education, marketing and fundraising for the FPS
PAC and Foundation. Jan Starnes will serve as the Director of Member Services and will manage both the
process and experience of membership as well as office accountability and
database management. Cam Fentriss
will continue her adept work as government relations consultant.
And last but not least, Margo Adams enters her 75th year as Executive
Director of the Society. She is the driving force behind the daily operations.
Her leadership is invaluable.
Success
revolves around member involvement - in FPS committees, attendance at the fall
meeting and increased interaction with members from around the state.
You may have heard all of this before but IT'S NOT CORNY, IT'S
TRUE. I look forward to this
exciting year. Please feel free to
contact me at:
e-mail:
dcastell@med.miami.edu
PH:
305.355.7077 (mornings)
305.446.0085 (afternoons)
Moving
Forward
Margo Adams, Executive Director Margo@floridapsych.org
And
then there was one... The visible
aspects of the merger of Florida's district branches have been accomplished or
are well underway. Much has been
written, much has been discussed, and much remains to be done.
Adding
three hundred members at one time from a well-managed but differently structured
database is a challenge that can be met. Adding to and managing that information in a database that is
already fraying at the edges is a challenge not so easily met.
Our database use is multipurpose and complicated.
Meeting
the challenges of a membership organization today requires more information on
member preferences and expectations, member interests and needs, and member
contacts with the organization, its programs and services.
Our information system needs work and we are researching solutions.
We
have already done some work on our communications systems. The office has reasonably up-to-date computer and fax
communication capability. We have
recently purchased a new telephone system that has added a line, and improved
the use of the existing lines. Members
will be able to call toll free. Busy
signals should decline significantly and if we are unable to answer a call,
there is an auto-attendant to direct calls to a limited number of voice
mailboxes. We hope this makes it
easier to get the person or information you need.
We
have added staff and assigned responsibilities as follows. Emily Grimm has returned as Associate Director, with primary
responsibility for meeting planning and marketing, continuing medical education,
and fundraising for the PAC and the foundations.
She will also serve as Managing Editor of Transference and manage our
electronic communications.
Jan Starnes is now Director of Member Services, and is responsible for the
process and experience of membership, chapter relations, office accounting and
management. She also handles most
of the referrals requested at the office.
I
continue to oversee legislative and regulatory activities, manage staff and
volunteer resources, manage liaison and outreach activities, provide budgetary
and financial oversight, ride herd on the APA and FMA, and we all focus on
communication and information.
We
continue to be assisted by Cam Fentriss, our talented and ferocious government
relations consultant. Cam
implements our legislative program and is always willing to lend her
considerable expertise to legal and business matters as well as advising our
PAC. Though not staff, she is
family.
Upward
and Onward The adoption of
reunification bylaws has provided a viable organizational structure.
The successful transition of officers from both district branches into a
single slate has provided diversity, experience and new ideas.
We are financially sound for the present, and planning for the future.
Moving to a statewide organization was the right thing to do.
President
Dan Castellanos has asked FPS leadership to prioritize membership, with the goal
of increasing both numbers and participation. FPS will evaluate our finances - making sure there are
adequate resources to meet member needs and organizational goals and objectives.
FPS will evaluate our administrative structure - making sure we are lean
and mean. FPS will evaluate our
programs and services - making sure we provide value and quality in everything
we present to members and the various publics we also serve.
It
is not possible to be all things to all people, but we can take the time to
learn what matters most to FPS members, and set about meeting those needs.
Cost and value must receive equal consideration.
And
in other news We have also been
busy with substantive psychiatric issues as well as organizational ones.
FPS member Ray Pomm serves on the Florida Mental Health and Substance
Abuse Commission. Dr. Pomm has been
thoughtful and provocative as a member of the Commission.
He has brought good ideas and enthusiasm to his task.
And has been a pleasure to watch. A
draft of the commission report should be ready for review by early fall.
This year's legislative session added several items to the commission's
charge.
Drs.
Yelton, Hernandez, Infante and Gabb, psychiatrists at the North Florida
Evaluation and Treatment Center, continue to battle for appropriate medical
responsibility and authority in the multidisciplinary treatment teams used at
the facility. The administrator
continues to try to portray this concern about patient care as physician
arrogance and desire for control. The
Department of Children and Families has yet to respond in support physicians in
spite of a declaratory statement from the Board of Medicine which establishes
that the administrator's Shared Responsibility Matrix does not meet the standard
of care expected of physicians.
FPS
continues to monitor plans to close GPW and shift patients to other facilities
or community based care. We have
expressed concern to the Secretary of DCF and received a letter assuring us that
there was a plan to place and care for patients displaced by the hospital
closure. Community and advocacy
concerns have not been quieted by what information DCF has released or made
public through the media.
FPS
has also responded to two members who asked for help in challenging 1) a
psychologist's attempt to get prescribing privileges at a VA facility in Florida
and 2) a psychology inspired assertion that current law requires that hospitals
give psychologists medical staff membership.
It doesn't. We welcome those
calls!!
Greetings
from FPS Headquarters! I am excited
to return to the Florida Psychiatric Society as your Associate Director.
One
of my responsibilities is to ensure that FPS has successful CME meetings each
year and I am so excited about the meeting we have in store for you this fall,
so Save The Date - the Fall 2000 Meeting will be October 5 - 8, 2000 in Fort
Lauderdale, Florida.
This
fall meeting will be the first meeting that South Florida Psychiatric and
Florida Psychiatric are officially one District Branch.
The reintegration of these two District Branches brings our membership to
over 1,100 members. Make plans to
attend the 2000 Fall Meeting - October 5 - 8, at the Hyatt Regency Pier 66 in
Fort Lauderdale. What a great
opportunity to see old friends and make new ones.
The Florida Psychiatric Society CME Committee has planned over 7 hours of
CME for you that include speakers from all over the country.
There will also be many wonderful opportunities for networking with
psychiatrists from around the state.
Auction
at the Fall Meeting!!!!
As you have requested, FPS will have a silent auction at the meeting in
Fort Lauderdale. This auction will
have vacation getaways and other prizes that you won't want to miss.
The auction will open for bidding on Saturday October 7 and will close at
the end of the Reception Saturday Evening!
Ask around, last year we had some incredible auction items available.
I know you won't want to miss this one.
You
should receive your Fall Meeting mailing shortly. This will provide you with the information necessary to
register for the Fall Meeting, to reserve your hotel room and to find out about
the interesting and exciting topics your CME Committee has provided for you!
This fall meeting will provide you the opportunity to earn your
much-needed CME as well as pay tribute to a very special psychiatrist, Tom
Buchanan. Tom Buchanan, M.D., who
passed away in 1997, helped to shape mental health care in Florida.
At the fall meeting we will pay tribute to Dr. Buchanan for all that he
did to promote the practice of psychiatry in Florida.
(For more information about Dr. Buchanan, please see article on page 13.)
This will be a meeting you do not want to miss. So, mark your calendars for a
fun filled weekend in Fort Lauderdale, FL.
Pharmaceutical
Representatives?
All members come in contact with pharmaceutical representatives and FPS
would like your help in finding out who they are.
If you would please forward their business cards to me I would greatly
appreciate it. The financial
success of our meetings depends largely on financial support from outside
sources including pharmaceutical companies.
Please send me their business cards or email me their mailing information
at Emily@floridapsych.org so that we may provide them information about how they
can help FPS by participating at our fall meeting. This meeting will be one of
our biggest and most important yet and we need financial support from the
pharmaceutical industry - so please, get them involved!
Don't
forget our web site:
http://www.floridapsych.org
Phillip Cushman, MD, spends an enormous amount of time and energy maintaining
the site and is constantly finding new and innovative ways to improve the site
and make it more user friendly.
FPS
Classifieds!
We have a classifieds page for members and non-members. This is a great way for you to advertise at a minimal cost!
For more information contact the FPS Office.
Email
Do we have your email address? We have had much success using email
to ask members about job openings and opportunities for Psychiatrists
moving into Florida. This is
very beneficial as it will increase our membership and fill job vacancies
you may have.
Email is an efficient and inexpensive method of communication,
which I love to use. Please
call me at 800-521-7465 or email me at Emily@floridapsych.org you would
like to provide us with your email address.
I
hope you have a wonderful summer and we look forward to seeing you in October in
Fort Lauderdale!
Auxiliary
Helps FPS,
Educates the Public,
Establishes Longterm Friendships
The
first auxiliary formed by spouses of any state psychiatric society, Florida's
Psychiatric Society Auxiliary has a long history of member assistance and
community education. But more than
anything, its members value the bonds formed among one another as they planned
and executed social and assisting projects.
While
this organization has provided some of the extras that make the Society's
meetings memorable, such as staffing, greeting teams and selecting and paying
for live dance bands for its semi-annual dinner dances, it has also taken on
siginifcant challenges.
For
example, in recent years the auxiliary has provided tasteful decorations and
furnishings for the Society's offices in Tallahassee and has helped pay for the
reproduction of a series of videotapes explaining the value and effects of
psychotherapy. These tapes are
disseminated upon request from the Tallahassee office to schools of nursing and
medical schools, to civic groups and to local chapters for use in their
community relations efforts.
The
Auxiliary also arranges outings and activities for spouses and children during
each semi-annual and leadership meeting, promoting good will and fellowship
among members. During the recent
semi-annual meeting in St. Petersburg, Auxiliary members went to the nationally
touring John F. Kennedy Exhibity after a brief business breakfast.
Although
the South Florida Psychiatric Society has not
had an active auxiliary in recent years, the FPS Auxiliary is hopeful to gain
new friends from South Florida and encourage spouses to come to the FPS Fall
Meeting at the Hyatt Pier 66 in Fort Lauderdale Florida.
The FPS meeting is October 5 - 8, 2000 and the Auxiliary will meet on
Saturday, October 7.
At
that time, Sharon Merritt, President, will open a discussion of "Welcoming
New Members, Determining New Directions" for the statewide auxiliary.
"We want members to enjoy and look forward to these meetings,
knowing that friendships made will continue over the years and that they will
have an opportunity to participate in meaningful, fun activities."
FPS
2000 Spring Meeting, Saturday April 8, 2000
George L. Warren, M.D., Editor
Drugs
differ from dietary supplements in vital ways according to Paul Doering,
Professor of Pharmacy Practice at the University of Florida College of Pharmacy.
Drugs must pass scrutiny of the FDA clinical trials whereas vitamins, mineral,
herbs, and dietary substances add to the diet in some way and the burden of
safety is shifted to the FDA to prove they are unsafe. A number of alternative
medicines are known to be effective and safe.
Among
the most widely used and considered to be safe is Ginkgo (ginkgo biloba) which
has mild posited effects when used to enhance memory. It is used for
cerebrovascular insufficiency or mild dementia. It is safe and comes from the
leaf of the plant and the active ingredient is flavinoids, which interact with
anticoagulants due to effects on platelet function and monoaminoxidase
inhibitors. It is usually well tolerated, although it takes several weeks to
take effect. Consumers are advised to look for a standard extract and select a
name brand.
Kava
Kava (piper myristicum) is a pharmacologically active depressant used to treat
insomnia, anxiety and seizures. It is safe for short-term use and comes from the
root. It interacts with alcohol and is often used recreationally, consequently
it can be abused.
St
Johns Wart is used for depression. In Germany, sales outnumber those for Prozac
by 7 to 1. No one knows the active principle. It has an effect on spontaneous
behavior. It has drug interactions with Indinavir used to treat HIV, and other
antiretroviral agents, oral contraceptives, cyclosporine, digoxin, quinidine,
SSRI's, MAOI's and has an effect on the P450 pathway. It is photosensitizing. Consumers should use a sunscreen if
they are to be exposed to sunlight.
Valerian
root (blaerana officianalis) is used to treat insomnia and anxiety. It is felt
to be safe for short-term use. The root contains the active part of valerinic
acid. Adverse effects include morning drowsiness and headaches.
Ephedra
ma hu or ephedrines and guarana concentrate consists of naturally occurring
caffeine plus 16 other ingredients. It is a potent source of caffeine and causes
tachycardia. The FDA is concerned about its use in consumers with cardiac
disease.
Other
supplements such as DHEA and phito estrogens including soy supplements are
considered risky for a variety of reasons and consumers are advised to read
about them and seek authoratative advice before using them.
Jorge
L. Armenteros, M. D., assistant professor of pediatrics and psychiatry at the
University of Miami, describes schizophrenia in children as a deterioration in
functioning, i.e. a failure to achieve the expected level of interpersonal,
academic or social achievement. Normal mental processes such as sensation,
perception, language, emotion, interpersonal relationships appear to go
completely awry. Children with the disorder lose touch with the real world. It
is likely more than one disease entity. Whereas one percent of all adults have
schizophrenia, it occurs in only 0.5% of adolescents and only 0.19% of children
below the age of 12. Schizophrenia in chilgren is rare, happening less
frequently than autism. The modal age of onset is between 21 and 22 years of
age. Females develop it later than males. It is thought that perhaps estrogen,
especially estradiol, may serve as a protective agent. Prevalence is higher in
poor urban areas giving rise to the "social drift" theory of mental
illness.
In
children, auditory hallucinations are the most frequently reported symptoms, but
visual hallucinations appear to be quite common as well. The onset is usually
gradual and can often initially present as a mood disorder. Treatment of the
family is critical issue. The prognosis is generally poor, but is better if
there are affective symptoms and a paranoid subtype. The earlier the onset, the
worse the prognosis.
The
most effective treatment includes educational and family interventions,
hospitalization to stabilize the situation using medications and psychotherapy,
which consist primarily of promoting ego boundaries and strengthening reality
testing. The neurotransmitters implicated include dopamine, acetylcholine,
seratonin and norepiniphrine. The newer antipsychotics offer great potential
benefits due to the fact that they treat both positive and negative symptoms,
thus improving functionality.
Clozapine
has been available since the early 60s. It is associated with a 4% weight gain
and a 1% risk of agranulocytosis at one year. The optimal dose 300-600mg. Side
effects include sedation, seizures, syncope, dizziness, and tachycardia.
Risperdol
was introduced in 1992. Its optimal dose is 4-6 mg per day. Side effects include
extra pyramidal symptoms, which are dose-dependent and weight gain, which is
significant. The satiety is blocked; since you don't know you are full, you keep
on eating. Weight gain usually occurs within about two months. Patients'
families must be educated. Time to maximum weight gain is 6-15 weeks and can
represent a serious threat to longevity due to a risk of hepatotoxicity due to
the rapid weight gain. It can cause fatty liver due to rapid gain. Liver enzymes
should be checked. If they are abnormal, they should be investigated. The drug
might have to be discontinued. As the dose is increased, the blockade of D2
increases so the incidence of parkinsonian symptoms increases.
Zyprexa
is effective in improving positive and negative symptoms. It has a low incidence
of extra pyramidal symptoms. It does produce weight gain which is about 7% above
optimal. Somnolence is usually transient.
Seroquel
is less effective, but the weight gain is slightly less. Its optimal dose is
above 300mg.
Ziprasidone
is not yet on the market. It is not clear that it will have a true advantage
over Risperdone.
Meeting
in the Windy City
George L. Warren, M.D., Editor
Senator
George McGovern's first contact with mental illness came immediately following
his nomination for the Presidency in 1972.
His selection of Thomas Eagleton as his running mate led him to defeat.
Senator Eagleton was a dynamic, well-respected man who also had a
well-controlled manic depressive illness. A
firestorm of stigma against mental illness brought down his campaign.
Senator McGovern called a trusted psychiatrist friend for advice and was
told to drop Eagleton from the ticket. Dismayed
by that suggestion, he called Carl Menninger, who expressed his condolences to
McGovern and told him he had already lost the election due to our nation's
inability to deal comfortably with mental illness.
As a result, other issues would no longer be a focus of the campaign.
Dr. Menninger's assessment was dead-on.
Senator
McGovern was summoned to the door late one night to learn his daughter had been
found dead in a snowdrift in Madison, Wisconsin, thus bringing her battle with
alcoholism to an end. She had a
long history of mental illness and had the benefit of innumerable inpatient
stays and psychotherapy. He
commented, "I feel sad when I
think of her and always will." His talk was the most poignant one given at
the Annual Meeting. Hopefully the
sharing of his experiences will help lessen stigma against mental illness and
substance abuse in this country.
The
Texas Society of Psychiatric Physicians has developed a Utilization Review
Complaint Service providing a benefit for members who experience difficulties
with managed care. It is now
possible to address those issues within the state rather than through the APA.
We plan to begin organizing a similar service in Florida over the next
few months and it will be discussed at the leadership retreat in June.
The
manufacturers of a Transcranial Neuromagnetic Resonance machine told me that
approval by the FDA is eminent. The
machine will be available for use within the next few months.
Billing codes will not be in use until January, so it will not be able to
be used by insured patients until then. Studies
show equal efficacy with ECT for depressed, non-psychotic patients.
Reboxitine, a new norepiniphrine reuptake inhibitor will not be on the
market until around the first of the yeas due to the FDA decision that clinical
trails on American citizens are required.
In
an effort to enhance the analysis and interpretation of quantitative data
already collected from the Practice Research Network (PRN), Substance Abuse
Treatment Focus Groups were held during the Annual Meeting. Being a participant
in a focus group was an invigorating experience.
Any APA member is eligible to join the PRN and be a participant in
gathering data to improve the scientific basis of our field.
Every
practice, whether private or in a mental health clinic where Medicare or
Medicaid patients are seen, should have a Medicare Compliance plan, according to
Michael Murphy, M.D. We heard
horror stories of large fines being levied against doctors in private practice
and medical directors of community medical centers due to coding errors.
In a four-hour CME course, the reasons were presented for having a
Compliance Plan and evidence of ongoing activity to support it should be
available in case either the carrier or Medicare officials chose to investigate
your practice. Members are
encouraged to attend a meeting concerning Medicare Compliance and develop a plan
of action to protect themselves against possible dire consequences.
A copy of a model plan will be provided for those who are interested.
The
Chicago meeting was the most heavily attended APA annual meeting ever held.
The description I have given of the events I attended is but a fraction
of the wealth of information available to those who fortunate enough to have
been there.
|